The previous privateness czar says Canadians’ basic privateness rights ought to trump enterprise rights in disputes

Posted by

The Trudeau authorities’s proposed overhaul of current personal sector privateness legislation ought to clarify to companies that privateness is a basic proper they need to respect, a parliamentary committee was instructed Tuesday.

This was the gist of former Canadian federal Privateness Commissioner Daniel Therrien’s testimony.

He instructed the Business Committee that it was the federal government’s promise to incorporate privateness as a “basic proper” – not only a “proper” within the present wording – within the explanatory functions part of the proposed proposal. Consumer Protection and Privacy Act (CPPA) not sufficient. He stated different departments should additionally clarify that privateness is a basic proper of Canadians.

These two sections are:

– Part (S.12) which offers with the “applicable functions” for which an organization can gather, use or disclose it, and lists the non-public info that corporations have to take into consideration. One among these rights ought to be the person’s basic proper to privateness, Therrien stated.

— and a piece coping with the Privateness Commissioner’s powers to advocate fines in opposition to an organization that breaches the CPPA (part 94). This part lists the elements that the Commissioner should take into consideration. One issue ought to be a person’s basic proper to privateness, Therrien stated.


“It appears to me from studying the parliamentary debates that there’s a consensus round the concept that privateness and financial progress via innovation isn’t a zero-sum sport,” Therrien stated. “The query usually isn’t which ought to prevail. Each privateness and innovation may be pursued on the similar time. This may solely be attainable in uncommon instances, and in these instances, privateness as a basic proper ought to take precedence.”

He stated that except the elemental proper to privateness was added to Article 12 – together with the addition to the needs part – the part would give higher weight to industrial pursuits.

Therrien agreed with present Privateness Commissioner Philippe Dufresne that the CCPA is an enchancment over the earlier model of the invoice, however each stated it nonetheless wants enchancment.

All of this may increasingly appear to be dancing on the top of a pin. Nonetheless, Canadian corporations topic to federal legislation have been ready for greater than a 12 months for motion on the proposed invoice. This may imply large adjustments from the present Private Data Safety and Digital Paperwork Act (PIPEDA) that corporations have been acquainted with for years.

One of many largest adjustments is the proposal that the Privateness Commissioner would advocate multi-million greenback fines for breaches of the CPPA to a brand new knowledge privateness tribunal.


Therrien – and Dufresne – warn that the court docket will solely delay the corporate, which should face the implications of violating the buyer safety legislation. They are saying the Privateness Commissioner ought to have the ability to difficulty fines simply as their counterparts in Europe and Britain do, with some administrative protections.

Nonetheless, corporations don’t need to see the Privateness Commissioner as choose and jury.

Therrien additionally reiterated his name for federal political events to be topic to a complete labor legislation. They will now gather and course of voters’ private info with out regulation.

Apparently, committee Chairman Joel Lightbond — a liberal — requested witnesses what minimal knowledge privateness guidelines could possibly be included within the CPPA and that federal political events must observe.

There might be rules requiring events to reveal how they use and shield the non-public knowledge they gather, and penalties might be imposed for violating the principles to again this up, Therrien stated.

He prompt that with out having to adjust to the Privateness Act, there may be a Canadian model of this legislation Cambridge Analytica scandalA non-public firm used a polling ruse to unwittingly gather private knowledge on tens of hundreds of thousands of Fb customers — together with Canadians — which was utilized in focused political adverts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *